Small HVAC contractors should consider a standard workers’ comp policy from a private insurer first, then the alternatives that fit their state and size: a state fund, a professional employer organization (PEO), pay-as-you-go billing, and the assigned risk plan as a last resort. Read this as general education, not legal advice.
Why does a small HVAC contractor have more than one option?
Because workers’ compensation is set state by state, and different arrangements grew up to serve different employers. A small shop with three technicians in one state has different needs from a growing company with crews in several states, and neither looks like a large employer that can carry its own risk.
What the coverage pays for is on our workers compensation page. Where to buy it is in our post on where to get workers’ comp for your HVAC employees. This post compares the options themselves.
What are the options, one by one?
Each option below answers a different situation. Most small HVAC shops will use the first one, but it helps to know what the others are for.
Option one: a standard policy from a private insurer
For most small HVAC contractors, this is the starting point. A private insurer issues a policy that covers your employees under your state’s law, and it usually includes employer’s liability. Premium is built from your payroll and classification, adjusted by your experience over time, and checked by an audit at the end of the term.
The things that make it work are accurate classification and accurate payroll. Our post on the HVAC workers comp class code explains how HVAC field payroll is classified, and how to reduce HVAC workers comp costs explains the experience modifier you can move over time.
Option two: a state fund
In North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming, the state fund is the only option, and private insurers cannot write workers’ comp. Washington’s Department of Labor & Industries says on its page Do I Need a Workers’ Comp Account? that coverage there runs through L&I or a certified self-insured employer.
Some other states run a state fund that sells coverage alongside private insurers. Whether yours does, and whether it fits an HVAC contractor, is a question for your agent or your state agency. The U.S. Department of Labor lists every state workers’ compensation agency.
Option three: a professional employer organization
A PEO takes over parts of your payroll and HR, and workers’ comp is often part of the package. Some small employers like having one provider for payroll, benefits and comp. Others prefer to keep their own policy.
If you consider a PEO, read three things closely. First, the full cost, including fees, not just the comp line. Second, how your technicians are classified under the PEO’s arrangement. Third, what happens to your coverage and your claims history if you leave. Commercial customers may also ask whose name is on the certificate, so check that a PEO certificate will satisfy your contracts.
Option four: pay-as-you-go billing
Some insurers offer to bill workers’ comp from actual payroll each pay period instead of from an annual estimate. It does not change what the policy covers. What it can change is cash flow and the size of the adjustment at the year-end audit, which is useful for a shop whose payroll swings with the seasons. Ask whether your insurer offers it and how it ties into your payroll system.
Option five: the assigned risk plan
When no private insurer will write a business, most states provide a residual market, often called an assigned risk plan. Oregon’s Department of Consumer and Business Services describes its assigned risk plan as coverage for employers who cannot get it in the voluntary market. New businesses and those with recent losses sometimes start here and move out as their record improves.
Real-World Scenario: An illustration, not a real case. A one-truck owner hires a first technician and gets quotes for a standard policy and a PEO. The owner compares the full cost of each, asks how the technician would be classified under both, and checks that the PEO certificate would satisfy the property manager who sends most of the work. The decision comes down to which arrangement the customer accepts.
What about self-insurance and Texas non-subscription?
These are real options, but rarely for a small shop. Self-insurance generally requires a qualifying employer with the financial strength to carry its own claims, and states set their own rules. The Texas Department of Insurance has a page on certified self-insurance, and Washington allows certified self-insured employers.
Texas also lets private employers decide whether to carry workers’ comp at all. The Texas Department of Insurance employer FAQ explains that employers who choose not to provide coverage are known as non-subscribers. Opting out has legal consequences and can cost you work with customers who require proof of coverage, so it deserves a conversation with an attorney and your agent.
How do your customers’ contracts narrow the options?
For many small HVAC contractors, the customer decides more than the insurer does. Property managers, general contractors, school districts and commercial building owners commonly ask for proof of workers’ comp before you start, and some spell out exactly what the certificate must show. An option that is cheaper on paper is no use if it produces a certificate your best customer will not accept.
Before you choose, pull the insurance section from the contracts that bring in most of your work. Look for three things: whether workers’ comp is required at all, what employer’s liability limits are requested, and whether the customer wants a waiver of subrogation, which is a promise that your insurer will not pursue the customer after paying a claim. Then ask each option, whether a private insurer, a PEO or a state fund, whether it can meet those terms. Our post on what commercial HVAC clients require lists the usual requests.
Where do the owners fit in each option?
Owners are one of the most state-specific parts of workers’ comp, and the answer can change which option makes sense. Some states let certain owners, partners or corporate officers exclude themselves from coverage, and some require them to be included or let them opt in. The rules also differ by business type, so a sole proprietor, a partnership, an LLC and a corporation can each be treated differently.
That matters for a small HVAC shop because the owner is often in the field, on the roof and in the attic, doing the same work as the technicians. An owner who is excluded has no workers’ comp benefits if hurt on the job and has to rely on other coverage, such as personal health and disability insurance. An owner who is included adds payroll to the policy. Neither choice is right for everyone. Ask your agent which choices your state allows for your business type, and get the answer in writing before the policy is issued.
What about the people you pay on a 1099?
A small shop often grows by bringing in help on a per-job basis. Calling those people contractors does not settle how your state’s law treats them. If a worker is treated as an employee under the law, an injury can land on your business, and the auditor may count their pay on your policy.
The safer habit is to treat every helper as one of two things. Either they are your employee, on your payroll and your policy, or they are a real subcontractor with their own business and their own workers’ comp, with a certificate in your file before they start. The in-between arrangement is where small HVAC shops get surprised at audit time or after an injury. When in doubt, ask an attorney about the specific relationship.
How should a small HVAC contractor choose?
Start with the facts, then match the option.
- Where do your crews work? A state-fund-only state decides the question for you there.
- Can you get a private policy? If yes, compare it with a PEO on full cost and contract acceptance.
- Does your payroll swing? Ask about pay-as-you-go billing.
- Are you in assigned risk? Build the record that gets you out.
- Do your contracts require proof? Make sure the option you pick produces a certificate your customers accept. Our post on what general contractors require from HVAC subs shows the usual requests.
When you are ready to compare, request a quote with your payroll and states attached, or read how we work.